Baseball theory to "cure" gayness

Curing Gayness with Baseball: A Critical Look at Unfounded Therapies

Attempting to "cure" gayness with baseball might sound like the premise of a satirical novel, but this approach was grounded in earnest practice among some therapists historically linked to the Mormon community. Guided by a belief in the possibility of shifting sexual orientation through manly activities, this theory has been a part of the larger controversy surrounding conversion therapy, a highly criticized and often harmful practice. The Mormon Stories Podcast has shed light on personal accounts of this bizarre and ineffectual method. Understanding these past practices is crucial for a thoughtful discussion on the roles of belief, therapy, and perceived masculinity within cultural and religious frameworks.

Baseball and Masculinity: Roots of an Unconventional Theory

The theory that one could engage in baseball or other stereotypically masculine activities to alter sexual orientation has its roots in misconception. During the late 20th century, conversion therapy practices variously sought to redirect same-sex attraction through reinforcing traditional gender roles. The LDS Church, among others, has historically wrestled with the reconciliation of religious beliefs and the lived realities of its LGBTQ members. Some therapists proposed that immersing oneself in gender-conforming behaviors could modify one's sexual orientation. However, looking back, it's apparent that beyond being ineffective, such methods were based on unfounded principles about the nature of sexuality and behavioral change.

Core Arguments: Flawed Foundations of Conversion Therapy

Documented experiences from participants, such as those shared on the Mormon Stories Podcast, reveal the underlying assumptions and processes of this practice. Participants were encouraged to engage in baseball as part of group activities designed to foster masculinity. The notion was simple: adopt the perceived traits of heterosexual men, and sexual orientation would follow suit. Predictably, the reality was that these exercises had no significant impact on one’s inherent orientation. As a tactic, baseball therapy was not only ineffective but also indicative of the harmful misconceptions of the era regarding the nature of sexual identity.