Why People Believe Irrational Things? - w/ Michael Shermer | Ep 1766

Why Do People Believe Irrational Things?

In an era marked by scientific breakthroughs and evidence-based decision-making, it might seem puzzling that many still hold beliefs that defy logic. Why do people believe irrational things? This question is not just philosophical. Its implications reach deeply into how we understand belief systems, including religious movements like Mormonism. Our discussion digs into these murky waters by bringing insights from Michael Shermer, a renowned skeptic and author, who joined John Dehlin's Mormon Stories Podcast to explore the nature of irrational beliefs.

Historical Context of Irrational Beliefs

Historically, belief systems have provided structure, comfort, and community to countless individuals. Religion and superstition have often filled gaps in scientific knowledge. Yet, this doesn't entirely explain why illogical beliefs persist in an age of information. According to Michael Shermer, founder of Skeptic magazine and author of "Why People Believe Weird Things," human cognition is predisposed to find patterns and causal links, sometimes seeing connections where none exist. This tendency has often led people to adopt irrational beliefs even when evidence suggests otherwise.

Mormonism, originating in the early 19th century, provides a case study in this phenomenon. Joseph Smith, the founder, claimed divine revelations and presented the Book of Mormon as scripture. Despite widespread skepticism, Smith's teachings attracted followers. The charismatic foundation and communal benefits of the early church were instrumental in maintaining adherence, even amidst controversies and disappointments.

Key Claims and Evidence